EVANSTON — It’s always going to be a barnburner when Evanston and New Trier meet.
In soccer, the rivalry between the two soccer programs has escalated. The teams consistently fight for Central Suburban League South Division titles. They last faced off in the state tournament in the 2021 and 2022 seasons.
The large crowd at Evanston’s Lazier Field was in for a special treat Friday night when the Trevians and Wildkits renewed their second-season rivalry for a sectional title.
Evanston’s Adriana Merriam and New Trier’s Annie Paden battle for the ball in the midfield. Photos by Michael Wojtychiw
By Michael Wojtychiw
NORTHFIELD – “See you guys at practice tomorrow.”
Those are the words that New Trier manager Jim Burnside told his squad after his postgame meeting with his players in the shed under their stadium following a 2-0 win over rival Evanston in the Maine South Sectional championship.
This sectional title is the seventh consecutive for the Trevians. It’s a streak that stretches back to the 2014 season, which marked the first of three-consecutive state title runs for the program.
“It was really great to say that,” Burnside said. “That’s what we tell them. We count down how many teams will be practicing, and we know only eight (Class) 3A teams will be practicing. It’s a great feeling.
“I really liked our grit today. I thought we possessed when we needed too, I thought we actually got a little better. The kids listened and adjusted as the game went on, and as this team does they grinded it out. That’s what they do.”
Friday night also marked another milestone for Illinois overall. Earlier in the day, the IHSA announced that with the state moving into Phase 5 of its COVID pandemic plan, crowd limits would no longer be in effect.
That meant that for the first time in the 2020-21 school year, stadiums were able to be at full capacity. And what better way is there to win a sectional title on your home field than in front of a raucous crowd for the first time all season?
“It was crazy to see so many fans out here tonight,” New Trier’s Morgan Fagan said. “The baseball team came in at some point (after a sectional title win over Oak Park and River Forest) and not having to wear a mask was nice. It felt normal. It was great.
“It was great having so many people out here supporting you, playing for your school. Everyone was so hyped for the win.”
“The environment was superb,” Burnside said. “Not having masks on the field was superb. I’m so happy for these kids that there’s a little bit of a normal season for these girls. They work so hard. They push themselves to be ready for this.
“They worked their tails off. We lifted a lot of weights in masks, six feet from each other, and they never once complained.”
“It’s a good feeling just to come out here and battle,” New Trier’s Mia Sedgwick said. “You realize what it’s all about, why you play. You come out and play against a good team. All the fans just make it better.”
The Trevians (20-1-4), the top seed in the sectional, and the Wildkits (16-3-3), the second seed, last faced each other May 19 when Evanston rallied late for a 2-2 tie.
That game is also the last time New Trier, its defense and keeper Wynne Hague allowed a goal.
Following that game, the Trevians were able to use what they learned in preparation for the third meeting with their CSL South rivals.
“We knew about their formation and those outside mids that were a problem for us last time. Our forwards kept pushing up, and there was no one tracking back on them,” Fagan said. “We knew that we had to cover on the weak side and cover on those. We also knew we had to match their level of intensity and aggressiveness.”
“We knew that we were going to be physical,” Sedgwick said. “Knowing that they were going to come in and come in physical and hard, especially if we go up 1-0, 2-0, we know that in that last 15, 20 minutes that they’re coming in hard. Knowing who they are, what their mentality is, really helped us know what to expect.”
“The one glaring difference is we didn’t allow any silly fouls in front of the net, because we know that they’re dangerous,” Burnside said. “Their number 14 (Nahla Dominguez) is dangerous on restarts, and we needed to make sure we didn’t give up any silly restarts.”
After much of the first half was played in the midfield with each team getting deep into the other team’s just a couple times, Fagan, the Boston University-bound midfielder/forward scored her 11th goal of the year when she took a beautiful cross from Alex Wirth and headed it past Evanston keeper Caitlin Fitzpatrick with 11 minutes remaining in the first half.
For Fagan, who is playing in her first and only season of high school soccer after playing two years with her club team and the missed season last spring, the playoffs have been something she never could have imagined.
“I honestly had no expectations coming into this, I’ve never had a playoff season,” she said. “It’s more intense than I thought. We played these teams in conference, but these are nothing like conference games at all. It’s so much more intense than I ever thought.”
Evanston’s best chance in the first half came when Nahla Dominguez took aim at Hague with a free kick from the same location she converted a game-tying kick during the May 19 contest.
Unfortunately for her and the Wildkits, the ball went just high and left the Trevians in the lead.
Evanston forced Hague to make five saves on the night, three of which came off the foot of sophomore midfielder Adriana Merriam.
Merriam, Dominguez and Breaylin Viamille will return next season for Evanston. With a squad that had only five seniors on its roster, the Wildkits were able to put pressure on the Trevians defense but to no avail.
New Trier’s Kate Dobsch put the match away with just under eight minutes remaining when she tapped in a free kick from fellow senior Jenna Birdsell. Like Fagan, Dobsch is playing in her first state playoffs after playing on her club team. The Wake Forest-bound player moved up from the defense to more of a midfielder position midway through the year.
With the win, the Trevians advance to the Glenbrook North Supersectional, where they’ll face Libertyville. The Wildcats are the lone team to defeat the Trevians with a 1-0 result May 1. Since that day, the Trevians have given up only three goals — May 17 in a 2-1 win versus Glenbrook North; and the 2-2 tie against Evanston, which were the most goals the Trevians allowed in a game this season.
That team from May 1 is different than the one that Libertyville will face on Tuesday in Northbrook.
“We’re already thinking about it,” Fagan said after the game. “We’re looking forward to practice and how it’s redemption time and we know Tuesday we want to come out and crush them. This is who we really are, and we’re here to beat you.”
“I still don’t think we’ve put together our best yet, but today was a great effort,” Burnside said. “We’ve grown into a very good soccer team, and we need to do what we do well. We need to possess; we need to attack the goal; and we need to be organized on defense.
“We need to be us. We need to be the best version of New Trier soccer. If we do that, whether things go our way or not, we’re going to have a shot at [a win].
New Trier’s Caroline Finnigan looks for a teammate downfield.
Evanston’s Breayln Viamille makes a move toward the goal.
New Trier GK: Wynne Hague D: Jenna Birdsell D: Anna Marshall D: Mia Sedgwick D: Ava Shah MF: Kate Dobsch MF: Caroline Finnigan MF: Annie Paden F: Alex Wirth F: Charlotte Dellin F: Morgan Fagan
Chicagoland Soccer MVP of the Match: Morgan Fagan, sr., F/MF, New Trier
Scoring summary
First half New Trier – Morgan Fagan (Alex Wirth), 29th minute
Second half New Trier – Kate Dobsch (Jenna Birdsell), 72nd minute
New Trier’s Mia Sedgwick follows the ball in a game against Evanston. Photos by Michael Wojtychiw
By Michael Wojtychiw
NORTHFIELD — Evanston and New Trier have arguably one of the best rivalries in the state. Both teams consistently fight for Central Suburban League South Division supremacy in pretty much every sport, making the rivalry even bigger.
The two teams came into Wednesday evening’s matchup atop the conference standings: the Trevians at 6-0-1; the Wildkits at 4-1-2. The fact that the Trevians handed Evanston its only loss of the year — overall and in conference — made May 20th’s game even bigger. And it didn’t disappoint.
Beating a team once in a year can be difficult. But beating that same team five times in a span of over a month and a half is extremely impressive and almost seemingly impossible. Continue reading →
Based off of the teams’ first match on April 19, a 1-1 draw, it was a safe bet that the Glenbrook South and New Trier sectional semifinal match Tuesday was going to be a tough one. Continue reading →
Nothing comes easy once you get into the state playoffs. Nobody wants to lose and when you’re the two-time defending state champion, every team is out to get you more than the last.
New Trier had its highest finish in the history of its program last year when the Trevians finished second in the state. The girls have wanted a chance to get back and win the big game. Continue reading →
On April 9, New Trier and Evanston faced off for the Warren Invite title with the Trevians coming away with a 25-20, 25-17 win over the Wildkits. Continue reading →
Evanston and Loyola Academy are separated by just 5.3 miles on Chicago’s North Shore, so when the neighborhood rivals meet it is sure to be a heated battle. Continue reading →
Michael Wojtychiw 